What supplements should a man in his 40s take?

Three questions under one: the muscle question, which is measurable, reversible and the one with a supplement answer; and the testosterone question, which is a slow decline, a blood test if symptoms, and a set of inputs no product matches

What supplements should a man in his 40s take is one question on the surface and three underneath, and the three have different answers, which is why the forties shelf, which answers all three with one formula, answers none of them. The first question under the surface is am I losing muscle, and the answer is yes: the rate of muscle and strength loss rises with each decade from the forties onward in a man who does not lift, measurable on a grip dynamometer and in the time to rise from a chair, and the loss lowers the number a man can eat without gaining, the strength available for ordinary life and, over decades, independence. It is also the one question with a supplement answer, because it is reversible at any age by the same inputs that build muscle at any age: resistance training two or three times a week, progressive, with protein at around 1.6g per kilogram a day, with the per-meal dose kept up at around 0.4g per kilogram at each of three or four feedings because the muscle responds less to small amounts as it ages, and creatine at 3 to 5g a day, which adds strength and lean mass on top of training in men of this age in the trials with the same safety record as in the young. A man in his forties who starts or keeps lifting with protein at the target and creatine has answered the first question, and the supplements on the forties shelf add nothing to that answer.

The second question is is my testosterone falling, and the honest answer is yes, slowly, and probably not in the way the shelf implies. The population studies find testosterone declining from the thirties onward by around one percent a year on average, a slow drift that most men never notice and that is dwarfed by the variation between individuals, where sleep, body fat and training move a man's level more than the average decline does: short sleep lowers it measurably within a week in the trials, excess body fat lowers it through conversion to oestrogen in fat tissue, and resistance training and a healthy weight support it. A man in his forties who sleeps seven hours, lifts and keeps his waist down has done more for the second question than any product on the shelf, and the products on the shelf, the boosters, were audited across dozens and found to have almost no data and no effect on the hormone. The second question becomes a blood test when there are symptoms: a persistent loss of libido, erections that have changed, fatigue that sleep does not fix, a loss of muscle despite training, or low mood, which together are a doctor's conversation about a morning blood test, interpreted against the symptoms and repeated before anything is concluded, with the treatment, if any, being a medicine under monitoring and never a supplement. The symptoms are also the symptoms of poor sleep, a thyroid problem and low mood on their own, which is why the test is a doctor's and not a shelf's.

Two questions answered, one by lifting with protein and creatine and one by sleep, weight and a blood test if symptoms, and the third question, the heart, which is a measurement rather than a shelf, with the forties list assembled, the boosters placed, the sleep that moves all three, and the worked example, which is the next section.

The heart question, which is a measurement at the health check and a doctor's conversation; the forties list assembled; the boosters placed by the audit; the sleep that moves all three questions; the worked example on the first question; and the verdict

The third question is am I at risk for the heart, and it is a measurement rather than a shelf. From forty, a doctor's practice in the UK offers a health check that measures blood pressure and the lipid profile and asks the questions, family history, smoking, weight, that the risk calculators use, and the answer to the third question is a number read by a doctor against those calculators, with the response being the plate, the training, not smoking and, where the calculation says so, a medicine with outcome evidence. No supplement has outcome evidence for the heart: plant sterols carry an authorised cholesterol-lowering claim and act on one number upstream, and omega-3 carries triglyceride and heart function claims with the UK lipid guidance telling doctors not to offer it for prevention because the outcome trials at supplement doses found nothing. A man in his forties who has had the health check has answered the third question with numbers; a man who has bought a heart formula has answered it with a label.

The forties list, assembled from the three questions, is the lifter's list with two adjustments and one appointment. Creatine at 3 to 5g a day, for the first question. Protein at around 1.6g per kilogram with the per-meal dose kept up, the adjustment the forties make to the lifter's list, for the first question. Vitamin D through the UK winter, for everyone, with its muscle function claim bearing on the first question too. Magnesium for the plate the survey finds a share of men short of, through the fruit, vegetable and wholegrain gap in men's diets, with its muscle function and tiredness claims. And the appointment: the health check, with vitamin D, B12 and ferritin added if a man is tired for no reason, for the second and third questions. The boosters are placed by the audit, which found almost no data and no effect on the hormone across dozens of products; the men's forties formulas are a vitamin D line with zinc and a herb; and the heart formulas have no outcome evidence. None of them answers a question a man in his forties is asking.

Sleep moves all three questions and is the thing the forties shelf never mentions. Short sleep lowers testosterone within a week in the trials, raises hunger and body fat, blunts the training that reverses muscle loss, and raises blood pressure; a man in his forties with a job, a family and a phone is sleeping less than he did at twenty-five, and the single change that moves all three questions at once is the hour of sleep he has stopped taking. The behavioural inputs that protect it, light, a consistent wake time, caffeine kept early and alcohol kept out of the evening, cost nothing, and a man who makes them before buying anything has bought the best product on this page.

The worked example is placed on the first question with the mineral's own claim: {FL}, 1500mg magnesium bisglycinate stated as 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, two capsules with the evening meal, with authorised claims for normal muscle function, normal protein synthesis, normal psychological function and the reduction of tiredness and fatigue, no hormone claim and no heart claim, which this page does not make, batch tested for lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium, UK made, 180 capsules for £19.99 at 22p a day, taken by a man whose plate is short of the foods that carry it. The full label breakdown is here.

The verdict: a man in his forties is asking three questions, and a supplement answers one. Am I losing muscle: yes, and lifting with protein at the target, the per-meal dose kept up and creatine reverses it. Is my testosterone falling: slowly, moved more by sleep, weight and training than by its average decline, a blood test if there are symptoms and never a booster. Am I at risk for the heart: a measurement at the health check and a doctor's conversation. Vitamin D through the winter and magnesium for a short plate sit beside the first answer, and the hour of sleep moves all three.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

What is the best supplement for a man in his 40s?

Creatine, because of the three questions a man in his forties is asking, am I losing muscle, is my testosterone falling and am I at risk for the heart, only the first has a supplement answer, and creatine at 3 to 5g a day adds strength and lean mass on top of resistance training in men of this age with the same safety record as in the young; the rest of the first answer is protein at around 1.6g per kilogram with the per-meal dose kept up and the training itself, with vitamin D through the UK winter for everyone and the other two questions answered by sleep, weight, training and a doctor's measurements.

Does testosterone really drop in your 40s?

Slowly: the population studies find it declining from the thirties onward by around one percent a year on average, a drift most men never notice and that is smaller than the variation between individuals, where short sleep lowers it measurably within a week, excess body fat lowers it through conversion in fat tissue, and training and a healthy weight support it; a man with symptoms, lost libido, changed erections, fatigue sleep does not fix, muscle loss despite training or low mood, has a morning blood test from a doctor, interpreted against the symptoms and repeated, and the boosters on the shelf were audited and found to do nothing.

Should a man in his 40s take a testosterone booster?

No; the audit of testosterone boosters across dozens of products found almost no data and no effect on the hormone in healthy men, and the inputs that move an individual's level, seven hours of sleep, a lower waist and resistance training, are larger than the average decline of the decade; a man whose level is actually low on a repeated morning blood test read by a doctor against his symptoms is treated with a medicine under monitoring, never a supplement, and a man without symptoms has nothing to treat.

What should a man in his 40s do about heart health?

Have the health check a doctor's practice offers from forty, which measures blood pressure and the lipid profile and asks about family history, smoking and weight, and read the result against the risk calculators with the doctor; the response is the plate, the training, not smoking and, where the calculation says so, a medicine with outcome evidence, while no supplement has outcome evidence for the heart, with plant sterols lowering one number upstream and omega-3 not offered for prevention in the UK guidance because the outcome trials at supplement doses found nothing.

Should a man in his 40s take magnesium?

If his plate is short of the foods that carry it, which the national diet survey finds a share of men's plates to be through the fruit, vegetable, nut and wholegrain gap in men's diets; magnesium has authorised claims for normal muscle function, normal protein synthesis, normal psychological function and the reduction of tiredness and fatigue, and no hormone or heart claim, which places it on the first of the three questions for a man with a short plate; the worked example is 300mg elemental at 80% NRV in two capsules with the evening meal for 22p a day.

Sources

1. The sarcopenia literature: muscle mass declines by around three to eight per cent per decade after thirty, accelerating after sixty, with resistance training and adequate protein the interventions shown to slow or reverse it. PubMed record
2. The testosterone and lifestyle literature: body fat, energy availability, sleep and resistance training are the modifiable determinants of circulating testosterone in men, with weight loss in men with obesity raising levels and prolonged energy deficit lowering them; supplements raise testosterone only where they correct a deficiency, zinc and vitamin D included. PubMed record
3. NICE guidance on cardiovascular disease risk assessment and lipid modification: do not offer omega-3 fatty acid compounds for the prevention of cardiovascular disease, in primary or secondary prevention, a position based on the outcome trials at supplement doses, with prescription omega-3 for raised triglycerides a separate specialist decision. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng238
4. Rawson ES, Volek JS. Effects of creatine supplementation and resistance training on muscle strength and weightlifting performance. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research 2003;17(4):822-831: creatine with resistance training produced around 8 per cent greater gains in maximal strength and around 14 per cent greater gains in repetitions at a given load than training alone. PubMed record

Related answers

• What supplements should every man take?
• What is the best cheap supplements?
• Is it safe to buy supplements from Amazon?
• What are the best third party tested supplements?
• How to spot fake supplements on Amazon?
• Are Amazon supplements 3rd party tested?