What should you look for in nature made supplements fake?

Old before fake: why a thin-margin pharmacy brand is rarely counterfeited, what a grey-imported tub loses on the way instead, and the verification mark the brand carries and how it is checked

What should you look for when you suspect a tub from an American pharmacy-shelf supplement brand is fake is a question whose premise is usually wrong in a useful way: the brand in question is a mass-market line sold through pharmacy and grocery chains at a thin margin, and a product like that is rarely worth counterfeiting, because a counterfeiter needs a margin to take and a product priced in pence a day does not offer one, while the premium brands beside it do. The counterfeit literature places the risk where the margin is, and a buyer worried about a pharmacy brand's tub is usually worried about the wrong thing. The right thing is age. The brand is American, sold in the UK mainly through importers and marketplace sellers rather than through a UK distributor with a shelf presence, and a tub that reaches a UK kitchen has often been bought in bulk in the United States, shipped by a third party and stored in two warehouses on the way, which does not make it fake and does make it old, and old is the problem to audit.

A grey-imported tub loses three things on the way. The first is shelf life: a product bought in bulk from an American retailer's clearance, shipped by sea and listed by a marketplace seller arrives months closer to its expiry than the same tub on an American shelf, and sometimes past it, with the date printed on the base in an American format a UK buyer may misread. The second is potency in heat: the stability guidance that sets a shelf life assumes storage at or below room temperature, and a container in summer or a warehouse without climate control runs hotter, which the oils and the less stable vitamins pay for, the fish oil oxidising and the vitamin C and some B vitamins degrading, so that a tub within date can deliver less than its label after a hot journey. The third is a responsible party: a tub imported by a third party carries no UK or EU food business operator's address, which means it is not a UK legal product, nobody here answers for it, and the buyer, having imported it themselves in law, has no one to return it to but the marketplace seller.

The brand carries a mark worth understanding before any of this, because it is the thing that makes the counterfeit question least likely to matter. Much of its range is verified under the American pharmacopoeia's dietary supplement verification programme, a voluntary scheme under which the manufacturer is audited, the product is tested for identity, strength, purity and disintegration, retail samples are bought and tested on an ongoing basis, and the verified products are listed in a public database. The mark is a real third-party verification of the product as sold in the United States, it is checked by searching the programme's database for the product, and it says nothing about what happened to a given tub on a sea crossing, which is the audit the next section runs.

A premise corrected, three losses named and a verification mark explained, and the audit itself, the expiry, the storage, the address and the one case where the counterfeit check still applies, with the worked example, which is the next section.

The audit of an imported pharmacy-brand tub: expiry, storage signs and the importer's address; the one case where the counterfeit check applies; the American label converted; the brand left unnamed; the worked example; and the verdict

The audit starts with the expiry, because it is the commonest failure and the easiest to read. The date is on the base or the shoulder of the tub, in an American format with the month first, and a buyer reads it as the brand prints it, checks it against today, and treats a tub within a few months of expiry as a tub that has spent its shelf life in transit and storage, which is worth a return under distance selling rules if it was not described as short-dated. The audit then reads the storage signs: a seal that is intact but a label that is faded or scuffed suggests a long time on a shelf in light; capsules that are stuck together, discoloured or softened suggest heat; an oil-filled soft gel that is cloudy or smells rancid when opened has oxidised; and a tablet that has gone chalky or crumbled has taken moisture. None of these is a counterfeit sign, all of them are age and heat signs, and a tub showing them is returned as not of satisfactory quality, which the consumer rights framework allows regardless of whether the seller calls it genuine.

The audit then reads the one line that settles most of the question: the name and address of a food business operator established in the UK or the EU, which must appear on any supplement sold here. A tub with that line was brought in by an importer who takes legal responsibility for it, which usually means it came through a shorter and better-controlled chain and that there is someone to return it to; a tub without it was imported by the buyer in law, through whatever chain the marketplace seller used, and the age and heat risks are the chain's. A buyer who wants the brand and wants the responsible party buys from a listing that shows the address, and a buyer who cannot find one has learned that the brand has no proper UK distribution, which is its own answer.

The counterfeit check is kept for the one case where it applies: a tub whose induction seal under the cap is missing, broken or printed differently from the brand's, or whose lot number does not match the brand's format or is absent, or which the verification programme's database does not list when the brand's own site says it should. In that case the three checks from the premium brand counterfeit page apply, the seller, the lot and the finish, and the unit is returned rather than swallowed. The American label is converted before any comparison with a UK product, percent Daily Value to NRV, international units to micrograms and a multi-capsule serving divided, which the supplement facts label page covers. The brand is not named in the body of this page, by rule, and the audit applies to every American mass-market brand that reaches the UK by import rather than distribution.

The worked example is placed with no journey to audit: {FL} is made in a UK facility certified to GMP and BRC, carries a UK address on the tub, has an expiry set from the fill date in a UK format with no crossing in between, an induction seal under the cap and a lot number on every unit that matches the batch certificate on request, 1500mg magnesium bisglycinate stated as 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, two capsules with the evening meal, batch tested for lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium, 180 capsules for £19.99 at 22p a day; a dry mineral in a capsule would survive a crossing, and this one does not have to. The full label breakdown is here.

The verdict: for a mass-market pharmacy brand, suspect old before fake. The thin margin makes counterfeiting rare and the long import route makes age and heat common, so the audit reads the expiry in its American format, the storage signs on the seal, the label and the capsules, and the UK or EU importer's address that says whether anyone here answers for the tub; the verification mark is checked in its database for the product; and the counterfeit check is kept for a seal, a lot or a database entry that does not match, which is rare and is returned.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

Are fake versions of pharmacy-brand supplements common?

Rarely, because a counterfeiter needs a margin to take and a mass-market product sold at pence a day through pharmacy and grocery chains does not offer one, while the premium brands beside it do; the commoner problem with such a brand in the UK is age rather than authenticity, because the brand reaches UK buyers mainly through grey import, bought in bulk in the United States and shipped by third parties, so the tub arrives months closer to its expiry, after heat that the oils and less stable vitamins pay for, and without a UK or EU address that would make anyone here responsible for it.

What does the verification mark on these supplements mean?

That the product is verified under the American pharmacopoeia's dietary supplement verification programme, a voluntary scheme under which the manufacturer is audited, the product is tested for identity, strength, purity and disintegration, and retail samples are bought and tested on an ongoing basis, with verified products listed in a public database a buyer searches by product; it is a real third-party verification of the product as sold in the United States, and it says nothing about what a given tub went through on a sea crossing and in two warehouses afterwards.

How do I know if an imported supplement has gone off?

By the expiry and the storage signs: the date is read in its American format with the month first and checked against today, and a tub within a few months of expiry has spent its shelf life in transit; a faded or scuffed label suggests a long time in light, stuck, discoloured or softened capsules suggest heat, a cloudy or rancid soft gel has oxidised, and a chalky or crumbling tablet has taken moisture; none of these is a counterfeit sign and all are grounds to return the tub as not of satisfactory quality under the consumer rights framework.

Why does the importer's address matter?

Because it is the line that says whether anyone in the UK answers for the tub: any supplement sold here must carry the name and address of a food business operator established in the UK or the EU, who takes legal responsibility for its compliance and to whom it can be returned, and a tub without that line was imported by the buyer in law through whatever chain the marketplace seller used, with the age and heat risks belonging to that chain; a buyer who cannot find a listing with the address has learned the brand has no proper UK distribution.

Could this site's magnesium be old or fake?

It has no journey to audit: it is made in a UK facility certified to GMP and BRC, carries a UK address on the tub, has an expiry set from the fill date in a UK format with no crossing in between, an induction seal under the cap and a lot number on every unit that matches the batch certificate available on request; it is 300mg elemental at 80% NRV in two capsules with the evening meal, batch tested for lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium, at 22p a day, and the same seal and lot checks that apply to any tub apply to it.

Sources

1. The counterfeit supplement literature: falsified and counterfeit dietary supplements are documented on online marketplaces, concentrated in high-value branded categories, with seller verification and packaging inspection the principal consumer defences. PubMed record
2. The stability and shelf-life testing framework: a declared best-before date is supported by real-time or accelerated stability studies showing the labelled content is still present at the end of shelf life, the test that connects a label number to a tub opened a year later. PubMed record
3. The American pharmacopoeia's dietary supplement verification programme: a voluntary mark awarded after a manufacturing audit, testing of the product for identity, strength, purity and disintegration, and ongoing surveillance testing of retail samples, used mainly by American mass-market brands and listed in a public database. https://www.usp.org/verification-services/dietary-supplements-verification-program
4. The food information regulations on responsibility: the food business operator under whose name a food is marketed is responsible for the information, and for a food imported from outside the UK that operator is the importer, who must ensure a compliant label in English with a UK or EU address. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2011/1169/article/8

Related answers

• What should you look for in 21st century supplements fake?
• What should you look for in fake supplements list?
• What should you look for in list of third-party tested supplements?
• What should you look for in certified supplements UK?
• What should you look for in nsf certified supplements?
• How to spot fake supplements on Amazon?