Why do I keep burping after taking fish oil?

Keep means you have tried something, so the page diagnoses in order, questions one to three

Why do I keep burping after taking fish oil is a different question from why fish oil makes you burp, because keep means the reader has tried something and is still burping, and the useful page is a diagnosis in order rather than a list of mechanisms, five questions with the likeliest answer first and the fix attached to each. Question one: is the softgel still going in before the meal, or on an empty stomach? This is the commonest cause even in readers who are sure they take it with food, because with food usually means just before eating, and a softgel swallowed on an empty stomach with the first mouthful behind it has already dissolved and floated by the time the meal arrives to hold it down, the reflux-and-posture literature's mechanism, so the fix is the middle of the meal, after several mouthfuls and before the last, a change of thirty seconds that stops most persistent burping on the first day. Question two: are you lying down within two hours? A bedtime softgel, or one at dinner followed by the sofa, rests a full stomach against the oesophageal junction and refluxes the oil that would have stayed down upright, so the fix is an upright hour or two after the meal and no softgel at the pillow. Question three: does a bitten softgel taste of paint or old nuts rather than mild fish? A rancid oil carries the aldehydes of oxidation, which are the smell itself and repeat for most of the day whatever the timing, and it is the answer for the reader who has done questions one and two and still burps all afternoon, the fix being a fresh tub stored cool and dark with the lid closed and finished within a couple of months, since no timing fix reaches oxidised aldehydes.

Questions four and five, the product answers and the reflux condition, and the diagnosis filed

Question four: is the oil an unstated form, or a large bolus? Many users report that an ethyl ester oil sits worse than a triglyceride one, the ethyl backbone being suspected in the reflux and the ethyl ester also absorbing poorly without a fatty meal, so a reader on a budget oil whose label does not state its form and who still burps after questions one to three tries a stated triglyceride or re-esterified triglyceride form next; and a large bolus of oil relaxes the sphincter more than a small one, so a reader on a 1200mg or 1400mg softgel, or on three at once, tries a 500mg softgel twice or splits the dose across two meals. Question five: do you reflux on other fatty foods too, a curry, a fry-up, a late cheese plate? If so, the fish oil is not the problem but the trigger, the reader has a reflux tendency or a reflux condition that any fatty food provokes, and the route is a GP for the reflux itself, the lifestyle measures the reflux literature supports, smaller meals, less alcohol and coffee, no late eating and a raised bedhead, and, as the product answer, an enteric-coated softgel that releases past the stomach and the sphincter altogether, the enteric literature finding fewer burps for most users at a cost premium, with an emulsion or an algal oil as the last resort for the reader who burps on everything. Five questions, in order, and a reader who reaches the end has either stopped burping or found out that the burping was never about the fish oil, which is worth knowing too. The diagnosis filed: before the meal or fasted as the commonest cause, lying down within two hours, a rancid oil that tastes of paint, an unstated form or a large bolus, and a reflux tendency that other fatty foods share, each with its fix, and the worked example being a fresh triglyceride-form softgel taken mid-meal, which answers three of the five at once, £14.99 for 90 at 17p.

The verdict, five questions that end in a fix or in the discovery that it was never the fish oil

Why do I keep burping after taking fish oil: because one of five things is still true, diagnosed in order, the softgel going in before the meal or on an empty stomach, which is the commonest cause even in readers who think they take it with food and is fixed by the middle of the meal, lying down within two hours, fixed by an upright hour, a rancid oil that a bitten softgel reveals by a paint taste and that only a fresh tub fixes, an unstated form or a large bolus, fixed by a stated triglyceride form or a smaller softgel, and a reflux tendency that other fatty foods also trigger, which is a GP's condition with an enteric coat as the product answer. A fresh triglyceride-form softgel taken mid-meal: Futuro Labs Omega 3 Fish Oil, one in the middle of a meal, 180mg EPA and 120mg DHA, lab-tested purity, 90 for £14.99 at 17p a day.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

I take fish oil with food and still burp, why?

Usually because with food means just before eating: a softgel swallowed on an empty stomach with the first mouthful behind it has dissolved and floated before the meal arrives to hold it down, so the fix is the middle of the meal, after several mouthfuls and before the last, which stops most persistent burping on the first day.

Why does fish oil repeat on me all day?

Because the oil is rancid: an oxidised fish oil carries the aldehydes of oxidation, which are the smell itself and repeat for most of the day on the breath whatever the timing, confirmed by biting a softgel for a paint or old-nut taste and fixed only by a fresh tub stored cool, dark and closed.

Would a different type of fish oil stop my burping?

Possibly, at questions four and five of the diagnosis: a stated triglyceride form sits better than an unstated ethyl ester for many users, a 500mg softgel twice relaxes the sphincter less than one large one, and an enteric-coated softgel releases past the stomach altogether for the reader who burps on every uncoated oil.

Could my fish oil burping be a reflux problem?

If other fatty foods, a curry, a fry-up or a late cheese plate, cause the same reflux, yes: the fish oil is then the trigger rather than the problem, and the route is a GP for the reflux itself, the lifestyle measures of smaller meals, less alcohol and coffee, no late eating and a raised bedhead, with an enteric coat as the product answer.

In what order should I try the burp fixes?

Timing first, mid-meal and upright, since it is the commonest cause and costs nothing; then a bite test for rancidity and a fresh tub; then a stated triglyceride form or a smaller softgel; then, if other fatty foods reflux too, a GP and an enteric coat, buying nothing until the free fixes have been tried.

Sources

1. The reflux and posture literature: lying flat within an hour or two of eating, and of taking an oil, increases reflux because the stomach's contents sit against the oesophageal junction, so a fish oil softgel taken at the pillow refluxes more than the same softgel taken with an upright meal. PubMed record
2. The fish oil oxidation literature: oxidation is measured by peroxide value, anisidine value and their combination as TOTOX, with the industry monograph setting limits of 5, 20 and 26 respectively, and surveys of retail fish oils finding a meaningful share above those limits, freshness being a quality dimension a label rarely shows and a certificate does. PubMed record
3. The ethyl ester fish oil literature: ethyl ester concentrates are the form of the licensed prescription omega-3 medicines, release only trace ethanol on digestion, absorb markedly better with a fatty meal than fasted, and are somewhat less oxidatively stable than triglyceride oils, so freshness matters more for them, with the polystyrene-cup test demonstrating solvent behaviour rather than any safety difference. PubMed record
4. The enteric-coated fish oil literature: an enteric coating delays a softgel's release until it has passed the stomach, reducing fishy reflux for most users, with overall EPA and DHA absorption similar to uncoated oil taken with food and a modest cost premium for the coating. PubMed record

Related answers

• Why do I feel better after taking fish oil?
• How can I stop burping after taking fish oil?
• What should you look for in fishy burps after taking fish oil?
• Why would my cardiologist tell me to stop taking fish oil?
• Why don't doctors recommend fish oil?
• Is fish oil worth taking for a natural bodybuilder?