Are there any reasons not to take magnesium?

The reasons not to, in the order most readers meet them, starting with the one nobody lists

Are there any reasons not to take magnesium is a question this site answers with a ledger, and the first entry on the not side is the one no supplement page lists: you are replete. A reader whose plate carries the reference intake, 300mg a day for men and 270mg for women from leafy greens, nuts, seeds, legumes, wholegrains and dark chocolate, has a met cofactor and an excreted surplus, and a daily capsule does nothing measurable for them at 22p a day, the deficiency pattern that governs every magnesium page and the reason by audit appears on every dose page here, so the commonest reason not to take magnesium is that the diet already did. The medical reasons follow: kidney failure and dialysis, where surplus magnesium accumulates and a labelled dose can harm, the one true cannot; the ask-first list, myasthenia gravis, heart block and slow rhythms, bowel obstruction and acute bowel flares, Addison's disease, pregnancy and breastfeeding, and under-eighteens by this site's rule; and a medicine that needs spacing or a status conversation, the tetracyclines, fluoroquinolones, bisphosphonates, levothyroxine and gabapentin that lose absorption beside it and the diuretics, proton-pump inhibitors and digoxin that change its picture, a reason to see a pharmacist once rather than a reason never. The belief reason, which does more harm than any of the medical ones because it is so common: taking magnesium for sleep, stress, anxiety, cortisol, testosterone or recovery, none of which it holds a claim for, and leaving the thieves uncaught, the insomnia untreated, the stress unmanaged or the hormone question untested while the capsule takes the credit for expectation, the safety-of-the-belief and two-clocks pages' cost.

The remaining reasons not to, the one reason to, and the ledger balanced

Three practical reasons not to complete the column. A laxative salt at the wrong hour: citrate or oxide at bedtime is a small-hours bathroom trip and citrate before a session is the runner's trots, so the reason is not to take those salts then, bisglycinate at the evening meal having no such hour. Hidden magnesium: a reader on a nightly magnesium antacid, a magnesium hydroxide laxative, a bone formula or a multivitamin with a magnesium line may already be at the guidance level before a capsule, the not-with page's fourth list, and adds a capsule to a total rather than to nothing. And the tested athlete with an uncertified tub: a competitor in a drug-tested sport takes only batch-certified products, and this site's worked example, batch tested for heavy metals and UK made but not Informed Sport certified, is a reason not to for that reader specifically, who chooses from the programme's database instead. The one reason to, on the other side of the ledger, is the diet audit: a lifter on a protein-heavy training diet light in greens, nuts, seeds, legumes and wholegrains, on a cut or a rice-and-chicken bulk, with heavy sweat losses or a drain in the history, has a shortfall that daily magnesium closes over four to eight weeks and holds, restoring the muscle-function, nervous-system, psychological-function and fatigue sentences the register names and the shortfall was costing, and for that reader the ledger balances toward taking it, at 300mg elemental as bisglycinate with the evening meal, reviewed yearly. The ledger filed: seven reasons not to, being replete, kidney failure and the ask-first list, medicines until sorted, the belief, the wrong salt at the wrong hour, hidden magnesium and an uncertified tub for a tested athlete, against one reason to, a shortfall found by audit, with the worked example being for that one reason, £19.99 for 90 days at 22p.

The verdict, a ledger that balances by audit

Are there any reasons not to take magnesium: seven, on a ledger, being replete so that the capsule is a pointless 22p, kidney failure and the ask-first conditions where advice comes first, a medicine that needs spacing or a status conversation, the belief that magnesium treats sleep, stress or testosterone, which delays real treatment, a laxative salt at the wrong hour, hidden magnesium already in the cupboard, and an uncertified tub in the hands of a tested athlete, against the one reason to, a diet audit finding a shortfall that daily magnesium closes and holds. For that one reason: Futuro Labs Magnesium Glycinate, bisglycinate, 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, £19.99 for 90 days at 22p a day, batch tested, uncertified.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

What is the main reason not to take magnesium?

Being replete: a mixed diet that covers the reference intake meets the cofactor and excretes the surplus, so a daily capsule does nothing measurable for that reader, the commonest reason not to and the one no supplement page lists.

Is there a medical reason not to take magnesium?

Kidney failure and dialysis, where surplus magnesium accumulates, are the one true cannot; myasthenia gravis, heart block, bowel obstruction and acute flares, Addison's disease, pregnancy, breastfeeding and interacting medicines are reasons to ask first rather than never.

Is it harmful to take magnesium for sleep or stress?

Not the mineral, which is safe within the guidance level, but the belief: magnesium holds no sleep, stress or testosterone claim, and taking it for one of them can leave the real cause untreated for months while expectation takes the credit.

Should a drug-tested athlete take this site's magnesium?

No: it is batch tested for heavy metals and UK made but not Informed Sport certified, so a competitor in a tested sport chooses a certified magnesium from the programme's database and matches the batch.

What is the one good reason to take magnesium?

A diet audit finding a shortfall: a training diet light in greens, nuts, seeds, legumes and wholegrains, a cut, a rice-and-chicken bulk or a drain in the history, closed at 300mg elemental as bisglycinate with the evening meal and reviewed yearly.

Sources

1. Department of Health. Dietary Reference Values for Food Energy and Nutrients for the United Kingdom. Report on Health and Social Subjects 41, 1991 (magnesium RNI 300mg men, 270mg women).
2. The hypermagnesaemia literature: the kidneys excrete surplus magnesium, so supplementation is safe for healthy adults within guidance and warrants medical advice in chronic kidney disease, where impaired excretion allows magnesium to accumulate. PubMed record
3. The magnesium and medicines literature: magnesium supplements reduce absorption of tetracycline and quinolone antibiotics, bisphosphonates and levothyroxine when taken together and are spaced from them, while proton-pump inhibitors and some diuretics lower magnesium status, a reason for medical advice in either direction. PubMed record
4. The sports supplement certification programmes: Informed Sport, Informed Choice, BSCG and NSF Certified for Sport test products or batches for banned substances, the assurance competing athletes rely on. https://sport.wetestyoutrust.com/

Related answers

• Is there any downside to taking magnesium for sleep?
• Which magnesium supplements are the best in the UK? A shortlist by the numbers
• What are the best magnesium tablets for gym in the UK?
• Are magnesium bisglycinate and magnesium glycinate the same thing?
• What medications should you not take with magnesium?
• Which five medications should not be mixed with magnesium?