What are the best supplements for muscle growth after 40 woman?

Two curves shift at once: the anabolic resistance curve every lifter meets after forty, the oestrogen curve a woman meets on top of it, and what each does to the muscle, the bone and the protein dose

What are the best supplements for muscle growth for a woman after forty is a question that a shelf answers with a women's blend and a collagen, and that the physiology answers with two curves, both of which move after forty and one of which only a woman meets. The first curve is anabolic resistance, and it is the same in both sexes: the muscle of an older adult responds less to a given dose of protein than the muscle of a younger one, so that the meal which triggered a full rise in muscle protein synthesis at twenty-five triggers a smaller one at forty-five and a smaller one again at sixty, and the dose has to rise to get the same response. The studies that measured the response in older adults put the per-meal dose near zero point six grams of protein per kilogram of bodyweight, against the zero point three a younger lifter gets away with, so that a woman of seventy kilograms after forty is eating around forty grams of protein at each of three or four meals rather than twenty at some of them, and a daily total near one point six grams per kilogram follows from the meals rather than being added to them. That curve shifts on its own, and the shelf never mentions it, because the fix is a plate rather than a tub.

The second curve is the one a woman meets on top of the first. Oestrogen falls through the perimenopause, unevenly and over years, and the fall does two things the muscle-growth question cares about. It accelerates the anabolic resistance, because oestrogen supports muscle protein synthesis and the response to loading, so that the per-meal dose that was enough at forty-two may be the floor at fifty; and it starts the bone loss that makes the years around the menopause the fastest-losing of a woman's life, with the loaded training that builds muscle being the same training that holds the bone. The second curve is why the list for a woman after forty is not the list for a man after forty with a different label: the protein dose is at least as high and arguably higher, the creatine evidence is specific to post-menopausal women training with load, and the training itself is doing two jobs, muscle and bone, where in a man it is doing one.

The list is built from the two curves rather than from a shelf, and each item is placed on what it does to one curve or the other. The protein per meal addresses the first curve directly. Creatine monohydrate addresses the first through the loaded training it supports. Vitamin D addresses both through muscle function and bone. The loaded training addresses both and is the item no supplement replaces. Iron addresses neither curve but the blood loss that continues while periods do. And hormone replacement therapy, which addresses the second curve at its source, is not a supplement and is placed with a doctor, which the next section takes in turn.

Two curves drawn, with the list built from them, item by item, the applicants placed by their evidence, the worked example, the doctor's conversations and the verdict in the next section.

The list built from the two curves: protein per meal, creatine with load, vitamin D, loaded training for bone, iron on a test, hormone replacement as a doctor's conversation; the collagen and the women's blends; the worked example; and the verdict

Protein per meal comes first, because the first curve is a dose-response curve and the dose is the fix: three or four meals each carrying near zero point six grams per kilogram, from eggs, dairy, fish, meat, pulses and, where the plate falls short at a meal, a protein powder measured to the gap, with the leucine content of a complete protein doing the triggering and no BCAA or amino blend adding anything a complete protein does not already contain. Creatine monohydrate comes second, at a few grams a day of plain monohydrate, because the trials in post-menopausal women find lean mass and strength gains when the creatine is paired with resistance training and little when it is taken without it, which makes the training the condition and the creatine the multiplier; the safety reviews find no kidney concern at the research doses in healthy women, and the water held in the muscle in the early period of use is a kilogram or so that is not fat. Vitamin D comes third, at ten micrograms a day through the UK autumn and winter for every woman and at a doctor's dose for a woman whose test came back low, holding authorised claims for normal muscle function and the maintenance of normal bones, which is the one supplement on the list that addresses both curves.

The loaded training is the item no supplement replaces, and the second curve makes it urgent: progressive resistance training with weights heavy enough to challenge the muscle, two or three sessions a week with the load rising as strength allows, is the intervention that builds muscle against the first curve and loads the bone against the second, and the bone trials in women around the menopause find that it is load, not repetition, that the bone responds to. A woman after forty who lifts light and often for fear of injury has chosen the training the bone does not notice. Iron is placed by a rule that differs from a man's: while periods continue, and in the perimenopause they can become heavier before they stop, a woman loses iron every month and may run low, so iron is a blood test, a ferritin from a doctor, and a supplement only on the result; after periods stop, the rule becomes a man's, and iron is never a guess.

Hormone replacement therapy is placed where it belongs, which is in a doctor's room and not on this page as a supplement. The UK menopause guideline covers it for the symptoms of the perimenopause and menopause, with a conversation about benefits and risks that depends on the woman's own history, and no supplement, no herbal, no women's blend and no phytoestrogen replaces it or should be sold as doing so. A woman with hot flushes, disturbed sleep, mood change or periods that have changed raises it with a doctor, and the muscle-growth question is answered beside that conversation rather than instead of it. The collagen and the women's blends are placed by their evidence: collagen is an incomplete protein low in the leucine that triggers synthesis, with the connective-tissue trials small and the muscle trials null against whey, so that it is a tendon bet at best and not a muscle protein; the women's blends sold for the menopause hold no authorised claim for muscle, bone or hormones and contain herbals, some with a liver record, that a woman on any medicine checks with a pharmacist before touching.

The worked example is placed on its claim and a plate reading, not on either curve: {FL}, 1500mg magnesium bisglycinate stated as 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, two capsules with the evening meal, holds authorised claims for normal muscle function and the maintenance of normal bones and no hormone, menopause or sleep claim, and the national survey finds a share of women below the reference intake for the mineral from a plate short of nuts, seeds, pulses, whole grains and greens; a woman whose plate reading finds that shortfall corrects it at 22p a day, batch tested for lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium, UK made under GMP and BRC, 180 capsules for £19.99, and a woman whose plate is full of those foods needs nothing from the tub. The full label breakdown is here. A woman who is pregnant or breastfeeding takes nothing on this page without a doctor or midwife; a woman on any medicine asks a pharmacist about spacing; and a woman with a kidney or thyroid condition asks a doctor first.

The verdict: two curves shift at once after forty, and the list is built from them. Protein near zero point six grams per kilogram at each of three or four meals for the anabolic resistance curve; creatine monohydrate at a few grams a day with loaded training, on the post-menopausal trials; vitamin D through the UK autumn and winter for muscle and bone; the loaded training itself, heavy enough for the bone to notice, which no supplement replaces; iron on a ferritin while periods continue; hormone replacement as a doctor's conversation and never a supplement; the collagen and the women's blends placed by their evidence and found short; and a magnesium on a plate reading and not on a curve.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

How much protein does a woman over 40 need to build muscle?

Near zero point six grams per kilogram of bodyweight at each of three or four meals, which the muscle protein synthesis studies in older adults point to against the zero point three a younger lifter needs, because anabolic resistance means each meal's dose has to be larger after forty to trigger the same response and the oestrogen fall of the perimenopause accelerates it; for a woman of seventy kilograms that is around forty grams at each meal from eggs, dairy, fish, meat and pulses, with a protein powder measured to a meal's gap, and a daily total near one point six grams per kilogram following from the meals rather than being added to them.

Should a woman over 40 take creatine?

Yes if she trains with load, on the post-menopausal trials: creatine monohydrate at a few grams a day paired with resistance training produced lean mass and strength gains in the trials in post-menopausal women, and little when taken without the training, so that the loaded training is the condition and the creatine the multiplier; the safety reviews find no kidney concern at the research doses in healthy women, the water held in the muscle early on is a kilogram or so that is not fat, and a woman with a kidney condition asks a doctor first; the product is plain monohydrate, the form every trial used.

Does the menopause affect muscle growth?

Yes, through the second curve: oestrogen supports muscle protein synthesis and the response to loading, so its fall through the perimenopause accelerates the anabolic resistance every lifter meets after forty, and the same fall starts the fastest bone loss of a woman's life, so that loaded resistance training is doing two jobs, muscle and bone, and the per-meal protein dose that was enough at forty-two may be the floor at fifty; hormone replacement therapy addresses the curve at its source and is a doctor's conversation under the UK menopause guideline, which no supplement, herbal or women's blend replaces.

Is collagen good for building muscle after 40?

Not for muscle: collagen is an incomplete protein low in the leucine that triggers muscle protein synthesis, the muscle trials find it null against whey at matched doses, and the connective-tissue trials that give it a tendon rationale are small, so that a woman after forty who counts collagen toward her per-meal protein dose has counted a protein that does not trigger the response she is dosing for; it is a tendon bet at best, taken alongside and not instead of a complete protein, and the per-meal dose is met from eggs, dairy, fish, meat, pulses and a whey or plant powder measured to the gap.

Does this site's magnesium help muscle growth for a woman after 40?

Not on either curve, and it is placed on a plate reading: it holds authorised claims for normal muscle function and the maintenance of normal bones and no hormone, menopause or sleep claim, and the national survey finds a share of women below the reference intake for magnesium from a plate short of nuts, seeds, pulses, whole grains and greens, so a woman whose few days of plate reading finds that shortfall corrects it at 300mg elemental at 80% NRV in two capsules with the evening meal, batch tested for four metals, UK made under GMP and BRC, at 22p a day, while a woman whose plate is full of those foods needs nothing from the tub, and a woman who is pregnant asks a doctor or midwife first.

Sources

1. The anabolic resistance literature: older and inactive muscle needs a larger protein dose per meal, around 0.4g per kilogram of bodyweight or 30 to 40g, to trigger the same synthesis a younger muscle reaches with less, with leucine content and resistance exercise restoring sensitivity. PubMed record
2. The review of creatine supplementation in women: women carry lower muscle creatine stores than men on average and respond to supplementation with gains in strength and lean mass across the lifespan, with evidence for mood and cognition during periods of low oestrogen, and with the same dose of 3 to 5g a day and the same safety record. PubMed record
3. The menopause and bone literature: bone loss accelerates in the years around the final menstrual period as oestrogen falls, resistance and impact training and adequate vitamin D and dietary calcium slow it, and hormone replacement therapy, decided with a doctor, is the treatment with the largest effect on bone and on vasomotor symptoms. PubMed record
4. The UK menopause guideline: hormone replacement therapy is the first-line treatment for hot flushes and night sweats, with cognitive behavioural therapy recommended for symptoms and low mood, and the guideline noting that isoflavones and black cohosh may relieve flushes with uncertainty about their safety, preparations varying, and interactions with other medicines, including St John's wort, as reasons to involve a doctor. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng23

Related answers

• What are the best supplements for muscle growth after 40?
• What are the best supplements for muscle growth and testosterone in the UK?
• What are the best supplements for muscle growth over 50 in the UK?
• What are the top 5 gym supplements for muscle growth?
• What are the best supplements for muscle gain in the UK?
• What are the best supplements for men over 40 in the UK?