Are ZMA supplements safe?

The first three headings, forms, toxicology and the long-term record, which is where the daily question is decided

Are ZMA supplements safe, and the variants asking whether it is safe every day, are answered by a safety file with the same five headings the glycinate safety page uses, and the daily question is decided under the third. Heading one, the forms: magnesium L-aspartate is on the positive list of permitted magnesium sources in the retained Food Supplements Directive, and the zinc in a ZMA is usually an aspartate or a methionine-based form, the permitted zinc forms including zinc L-aspartate and zinc methionine sulphate, so a UK-compliant ZMA uses assessed forms and the exact zinc form is read off the ingredients list, the one place a formula can vary. Heading two, the toxicology at the men's dose: 30mg of zinc causes nausea and stomach upset when fasted, the classic bedtime instruction's problem, 450mg of magnesium as aspartate sits at or over the 400mg supplemental guidance level in a middling salt and loosens stools for a good share of users, and 10.5mg of B6 sits at the 10mg long-term guidance level with no effect at that dose, so the short-term toxicology is a gut, not an organ, and a healthy adult taking ZMA for a few weeks is safe in the ordinary sense. Heading three, the long-term record, which is where daily fails: the UK expert group's guidance level for supplemental zinc is 25mg a day because sustained intake above it depletes copper, zinc inducing the intestinal protein that binds both minerals, an effect that accumulates over months and can produce anaemia and neurological symptoms at the extreme, and the men's ZMA dose delivers 30mg a day before any multivitamin, zinc lozenge or fortified food is counted, so a man taking ZMA every day for months is taking a zinc dose the guidance says not to sustain, which is the honest answer to safe every day, no on the zinc line while yes on the others, and the women's 20mg dose passing where the men's does not.

Headings four and five, interactions and populations, and the file filed

Heading four, interactions, which are the two minerals' spacing rules: the tetracycline and quinolone antibiotics chelate with both zinc and magnesium and are spaced by hours, the bisphosphonates and levothyroxine are reduced by minerals and kept hours away, gabapentin is spaced from magnesium, and zinc's own notes add that high zinc interferes with copper and, at the very high doses of the balance study, with magnesium, while penicillins, cephalosporins, macrolides and ordinary supplements need no spacing, the standing rule being the whole cupboard to a pharmacist once for anyone on regular medication. Heading five, populations: the usual short list, anyone with kidney disease where magnesium accumulates, anyone with myasthenia gravis where magnesium can worsen weakness, anyone with heart block or a very slow pulse, anyone pregnant or breastfeeding where a midwife decides, under-eighteens by this site's rule, and, specific to ZMA's zinc, anyone with a known copper deficiency or on long-term high zinc for a medical reason, a doctor's question. The file filed: ZMA is safe short-term for a healthy adult, its forms permitted, its toxicology a gut matter, its interactions spacing rules and its populations the usual list, and it is not a sensible daily supplement at the men's dose because 30mg of zinc sustained exceeds the level set to protect copper, the daily answer resting on the zinc and the fix being the two-tub version, magnesium bisglycinate at 300mg elemental under its level, safe daily, and a separate zinc at 10 to 15mg by audit under its own, the worked example being the magnesium half, £19.99 for 90 days at 22p, taken with dinner every day without a copper question.

The verdict, safe for a while and not a daily dose of zinc

Are ZMA supplements safe: short-term for a healthy adult, yes, on a file of permitted forms, a gut-level toxicology, spacing interactions and the usual population list, and every day at the men's dose, no on the one line that matters for daily use, 30mg of zinc sustained exceeding the 25mg guidance level set to protect copper stores over months, while the women's 20mg dose passes and the two-tub version, magnesium bisglycinate under its level and a small zinc by audit under its own, is safe daily without the question. The magnesium half: Futuro Labs Magnesium Glycinate, bisglycinate, 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, £19.99 for 90 days at 22p a day.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

Is it safe to take ZMA every day?

At the men's dose, not as a long-term habit: 30mg of zinc a day exceeds the UK guidance level of 25mg, set because sustained zinc above it depletes copper over months, while the magnesium and B6 lines are tolerable and the women's 20mg zinc dose passes.

What happens if you take too much zinc for a long time?

Copper depletion: zinc induces the intestinal protein that binds both minerals, so sustained high zinc lowers copper absorption and can produce anaemia and neurological symptoms at the extreme, the reason the 25mg guidance level exists.

Are the minerals in ZMA approved forms in the UK?

Magnesium L-aspartate is on the positive list of permitted magnesium sources, and zinc aspartate and methionine-based zinc forms are among the permitted zinc sources, so a UK-compliant ZMA uses assessed forms, the exact zinc form being read off the ingredients list.

Does ZMA interact with any medicines?

By spacing: tetracycline and quinolone antibiotics chelate with both minerals and are spaced by hours, bisphosphonates and levothyroxine are kept hours away, and gabapentin is spaced from magnesium, with a pharmacist sorting the cupboard for anyone on regular medication.

Who should not take ZMA?

Anyone with kidney disease, myasthenia gravis, heart block or a very slow pulse, anyone pregnant or breastfeeding, under-eighteens by this site's rule, and anyone with a known copper deficiency or on medical high-dose zinc, all of whom ask a doctor first.

Sources

1. Expert Group on Vitamins and Minerals. Safe Upper Levels for Vitamins and Minerals. Food Standards Agency, 2003 (magnesium guidance level 400mg a day from supplements). https://cot.food.gov.uk/sites/default/files/vitmin2003.pdf
2. The zinc and magnesium interaction literature: very high supplemental zinc, in the region of 140mg a day, reduced magnesium absorption and balance in a metabolic study, while ordinary supplemental doses of 10 to 25mg show no meaningful interaction, and high zinc also depletes copper. PubMed record
3. The retained Food Supplements Directive, Annex II: magnesium bisglycinate, citrate, oxide and the other permitted magnesium forms are listed as authorised sources for use in food supplements, the positive list a form must be on to be sold. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/eudr/2002/46/annex/II
4. The magnesium and medicines literature: magnesium supplements reduce absorption of tetracycline and quinolone antibiotics, bisphosphonates and levothyroxine when taken together and are spaced from them, while proton-pump inhibitors and some diuretics lower magnesium status, a reason for medical advice in either direction. PubMed record

Related answers

• Which magnesium supplements are the best in the UK? A shortlist by the numbers
• What are the side effects of taking ZMA?
• What are the benefits of ZMA for men?
• Is ZMA worth it?
• What is the best ZMA brand in the UK?
• What supplements can help with muscle twitching?