Why does a lion's mane make me feel weird?

The label experiment: how the psychology of emotion showed that a feeling is a signal plus an explanation, what the successors added, and why a newly swallowed capsule is the handiest explanation a body ever gets

Why does a lion's mane make me feel weird is a question the psychology of emotion answered sixty years ago, before any mushroom was in a capsule, and the answer is the most useful thing a person with the feeling can read. In the early 1960s Schachter and Singer gave volunteers an injection of adrenaline, told some of them accurately what it would do, told others nothing or something false, and then placed each in a room with an actor who behaved either euphorically or angrily. The adrenaline was identical in every arm, and so was the bodily signal it produced, a faster heart, a flush, a tremor. What differed was the explanation available, and the volunteers who had not been told what the injection would do reported feeling whatever the room suggested, excitement beside the euphoric actor and anger beside the angry one, while those who had an accurate explanation for their racing heart reported little emotion at all. The two-factor theory that came out of it holds that a feeling is built from two parts, a physiological signal and a label the mind supplies from context, and that the same signal becomes different feelings under different labels. The successors refined it into the misattribution of arousal literature, which showed the effect with ordinary signals rather than injected ones: the pounding heart from crossing a high bridge was reported as attraction to a stranger met on the far side, the residual arousal from a staircase was reported as anger at a provocation, and in the medical versions, ordinary bodily noise, a skipped beat, a tight chest, a wave of fatigue, became a symptom the moment a person had something to attribute it to. The label does not create the signal; it decides what the signal feels like, and whether it feels like anything at all.

A newly swallowed substance is the handiest label a body ever gets. A person who has just taken a new capsule has a ready explanation for everything their body does in the following hours, and bodies do a great deal: the heart skips beats daily, the stomach gurgles, the afternoon brings a dip, a hard set leaves a tightness, standing up quickly brings a swim, and a short night leaves a heaviness that arrives at two. On an ordinary day each of these passes unlabelled and unfelt. On the day a capsule was started, each is a candidate effect, and a candidate effect of an unfamiliar substance is labelled weird, because weird is the word for a signal whose explanation is new. The word mushroom helps, carrying psilocybin's reputation onto an unrelated fungus, and the nerve-growth story helps more, inviting a person to monitor their head for a change, and monitoring finds things, since attention to the body amplifies the signals it finds and the interoception literature treats that amplification as a core mechanism of anxious and strange feelings in people with nothing in them at all.

Why the mushroom supplies the label and not the signal, the ordinary signals that get labelled, the test that removes the label, the one timing that is a signal in its own right, and the honest buy

Lion's mane supplies the label and not the signal, and the distinction can be checked. For the mushroom to be the signal, it would have to do something to the body a person could perceive, and it does not: it contains no stimulant, no sedative, no psychoactive compound and nothing with receptor activity in any assay, its one pharmacological story is a trophic protein acting over weeks in cell culture, and the one human study that asked participants how they felt, over the hours after a single 1.8g dose and again after four weeks of daily capsules, found no change in mood, perceived stress or alertness against placebo. The capsule is inert on the felt axis, which makes it a pure label, an explanation with no signal of its own, waiting for the body to supply one. The signals it gets attached to are the ordinary ones, and they can be listed. The caffeine in a mushroom coffee, 50 to 100mg a serving, supplies a real signal, a pulse rise and a lift, that is labelled with the mushroom's name. A short night supplies a heaviness at two in the afternoon. A hard session supplies a tight chest and a flutter on the stairs. Hunger on a cut supplies a hollow, light-headed swim. A cold coming on supplies a day of feeling off before the symptoms. And the mushroom's own fibre supplies the one signal that is actually its own, the bloating, cramping or looseness that grams of beta-glucan can produce in a minority at one to three hours, which is a real digestive event rather than a weird feeling and is fixed by a smaller dose with food.

The test that follows from the label experiment is to remove the label, and it is the only test on this site that costs nothing and takes no diary. Take the capsule with water, not coffee, in the middle of an ordinary day, with no story attached, no reading of forum threads beforehand and no monitoring of the head or the body for an effect afterward, and go about the day; a signal that was being labelled by the capsule will either not arrive, because it was the coffee or the expectation, or will arrive and be recognised for what it is, a short night or a hard set, because the capsule is no longer the handiest explanation. People who run the test usually find the weird fails to turn up, which is the two-factor theory working in reverse: no label, no feeling. The one timing that is not a label but a signal in its own right is the rare allergic reaction, documented in a small number of lion's mane case reports and most likely in people with mould allergy or asthma: a rash, itching, hives, swelling of the lips or face, a tight throat or wheeze within minutes to two hours of a dose is the mushroom's protein being recognised by the immune system, and it is treated as allergy first, stop, no further dose, urgent help if breathing is affected, with no label experiment needed. The honest buy for a person who wants to stop feeling weird is a capsule sold without a label to attach: the worked example, {FLLM}, a stated 5:1 fruiting body extract labelled 1500mg mushroom equivalent per capsule, 120 days for £15.49 at 13p, UK made, independently lab tested, caffeine free so that it carries no signal of its own into the experiment, and claim-free so that it hands the body no story to tell.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

Why do I feel strange after taking lion's mane?

Because a feeling is built from a bodily signal and a label the mind supplies, and a newly swallowed capsule is the handiest label a body ever gets: the two-factor experiments showed identical adrenaline injections felt like excitement or anger depending on the explanation handed over, and the ordinary signals of a day, a coffee blend's caffeine, a short night's heaviness, a hard set's flutter, a cut's light-headedness, become strange the moment a new capsule is available to explain them; the mushroom has no signal of its own.

Is the weird feeling from lion's mane a sign it is working?

No; the mushroom's one measured effect appeared on a clinician's cognitive scale at week eight in impaired older adults and was never felt by them, the one study that asked how people felt found no change in mood, stress or alertness, and nothing in the capsule's pharmacology produces a sensation on any timescale; a weird feeling is a label attached to an ordinary signal, or the fibre's digestive event at one to three hours, and in neither case is it the mushroom working.

How do I stop feeling weird on lion's mane?

Remove the label: take the capsule with water rather than a coffee blend, in the middle of an ordinary day, having read no forum threads beforehand and monitoring nothing afterward, and go about the day; a signal that was being labelled by the capsule either fails to arrive, because it was the coffee or the expectation, or arrives and is recognised as the short night or the hard set it was; if the feeling is bloating or looseness at one to three hours, that is the fibre, and a smaller dose with food fixes it.

Can lion's mane cause a feeling that is actually dangerous?

One, and it is a signal rather than a label: an allergic reaction, documented in a small number of case reports and most likely in people with mould allergy or asthma, presenting within minutes to two hours as rash, itching, hives, swelling of the lips or face, a tight throat or wheeze; that is the immune system recognising a fungal protein, it means stop, take no further dose and seek urgent help if breathing is affected, and it is the reason a first capsule of any new mushroom product is taken at home.

Does the word mushroom make people feel things?

Yes, measurably: the word carries the psychedelic mushroom's reputation onto an unrelated culinary fungus, and the nerve-growth story on lion's mane tubs invites a person to monitor their head for a change, and the misattribution and nocebo literatures both show that an expectation plus attention to the body produces reportable feelings from ordinary bodily noise; a lion's mane capsule contains no psilocybin and no psychoactive compound, and the feelings the word produces arrive without any help from the fungus.

Sources

1. The misattribution of arousal literature: Schachter and Singer's two-factor experiments and their successors show that an emotional or bodily state is built from a physiological signal plus a label supplied by context, so that the same arousal is reported as excitement, anxiety or illness depending on the explanation available, and a newly taken substance is the most available explanation for any sensation that follows it. PubMed record
2. The interoception and anxiety literature: anxious states are built from bodily signals, heart rate, breathing, muscle tension, and the interpretation of those signals, with heightened attention to the body and catastrophic interpretation of ordinary sensations a core mechanism of anxiety, so that monitoring one's body for an effect can itself produce the anxious feeling being monitored for. PubMed record
3. The nocebo literature: negative expectations produce real symptoms, nausea, headache, dizziness and malaise, in people given inert substances, with warnings, forum reports and attention to bodily sensation increasing the rate, which is the first explanation for a new vague sensation after starting any supplement. PubMed record
4. Docherty S, Doughty FL, Smith EF. The acute and chronic effects of lion's mane mushroom supplementation on cognitive function, stress and mood in young adults: a double-blind, parallel groups, pilot study. Nutrients 2023;15(22):4842. PubMed record

Related answers

• Can lion's mane make you feel weird?
• Does lion's mane make you feel funny?
• Does lion's mane make you high?
• Does lion's mane make you sleepy?
• Does lion's mane make you gain weight?
• Why do I feel weird after taking lion mane?