What are the top 10 bodybuilding supplements in the UK?

Ten names as six eras: how the bodybuilding shelf's top ten arrived one era at a time, which products each era sold, and what the trials did to each when they caught up

What are the top 10 bodybuilding supplements in the UK is a question whose answer on every other page is a ranking, and the honest answer is a history, because the ten names on the bodybuilding shelf arrived one era at a time, each era's product was the best-seller until the trials caught up with it, and reading the list as a sequence shows which names the trials made bigger and which they shrank. The first era sold protein powder and desiccated liver tablets: the powder survives, as the gram of protein rather than the brand, and the liver tablets, sold as a source of everything, were the first product the evidence quietly retired when a varied diet turned out to carry the same. The second era sold free amino acids, on the theory that the building blocks taken apart would build faster than the protein that contained them; the trials that fed them found the opposite, that amino acids taken as a complete protein did the same job at a fraction of the price, and the era's product survives today as the amino acid blend at ten times the cost of the whey beside it. The third era brought creatine, and creatine is the only product on the list that the trials made bigger rather than smaller: it arrived with a claim it could not yet support and left two decades of trials with an authorised claim for performance in successive bursts of short-term high-intensity exercise, a meta-analysis showing around eight per cent more maximal strength and fourteen per cent more repetitions than training alone, and one to two kilograms of lean mass over a block, at a price that fell to pence as the molecule became a commodity. The fourth era sold nitric oxide boosters and the first pre-workouts, arginine and then citrulline for the pump and a stimulant blend for the session; the pump survived as a sensation and the mass trial never arrived, and the pre-workout's measurable effect turned out to be its caffeine, which the fifth era kept and surrounded with the tingle of beta-alanine. The fifth era sold branched-chain amino acids, testosterone boosters and fat burners, the three products that the trials treated most unkindly: the branched-chain amino acids were shown to be unable to sustain muscle protein synthesis without the other essential amino acids, so that in anyone eating adequate protein they add nothing a complete protein does not; the testosterone boosters were audited at fifty products with under a quarter showing any data and none with a trial on muscle; and the fat burners were measured in the meta-analyses at a few hundred grams over months. The sixth era, the current one, sells collagen, greens powders and nootropics to bodybuilders, and none of the three has been tested in a bodybuilder for a bodybuilding outcome, which is where the history stops and the shelf is.

Read as a sequence, the list has a shape: each era's product was sold on a mechanism, the trials tested the outcome, and the product either earned a claim, which one did, or became a footnote, which seven did, with protein and caffeine surviving as commodities rather than as the brands that sold them.

The three left standing and what each is bought as, the seven footnotes read as the eras that made them, the worked example for a reason the list never gave, and the verdict

Three products are left standing when the trials have finished with the ten, and each is bought as something plainer than the era that sold it. Creatine is bought as creatine monohydrate, the plain powder with a purity statement at 3 to 5g a day, since every branded form that followed, the hydrochlorides, the buffered versions and the capsules, costs more for the same molecule and no trial shows it doing more; it is the one product on the list with an authorised claim, the longest mark on the lean-mass ruler and the strength meta-analysis behind it, and a bodybuilder who takes nothing else has taken the one thing the list proved. Protein is bought as the gram rather than the brand, for the lifter whose food falls short of about 1.6 grams per kilogram a day, where the meta-analysis finds its 0.3 kilograms of fat-free mass, and for nobody above it; a whey is read for grams of protein per serving against the high protein threshold and for the amino spiking that inflates the number, and the first era's powder survives as a convenience rather than a supplement. Caffeine is bought as a tablet at 3 to 6mg per kilogram for the session that needs it, since the pre-workout's measurable effect is its caffeine and the rest of the tub is the fourth and fifth eras' tingle and pump at ten times the price. The seven footnotes are read as the eras that produced them: the liver tablets and free amino acids as products that a varied diet and a complete protein replaced; the nitric oxide boosters as a pump without a mass trial; the branched-chain amino acids as the fifth era's cleverest error, a part sold as more than the whole; the testosterone boosters as an audited empty shelf; the fat burners as grams against the ledger's kilograms; and the collagen, greens and nootropics as the current era's products awaiting the trials that will sort them, with the honest prediction that collagen's tendon protocol may survive as a timing and the other two will not.

The worked example is not on the list and is on the shelf for a reason the list never gave: {FL}, 1500mg magnesium bisglycinate stated as 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, two capsules with the evening meal, carrying the authorised claims for normal muscle function, normal protein synthesis, electrolyte balance and the reduction of tiredness and fatigue, taken because the national diet survey finds a large share of young men short of the mineral and not because any era sold it to bodybuilders, batch tested for lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium with the certificate on request, UK made under GMP and BRC, 180 capsules for £19.99 at 22p a day. The verdict on the top 10 bodybuilding supplements in the UK is that the ten are six eras of selling and one era of testing, that the trials left creatine, protein as grams and caffeine as a tablet standing and turned the other seven into the footnotes of the decades that sold them, and that a bodybuilder who buys the three as commodities has bought everything the history proved, for less than the price of any one product from the eras that did not.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

What are the top bodybuilding supplements that actually work?

Three of the shelf's ten, once the trials have finished with the eras that sold them: creatine monohydrate, the only product the trials made bigger, with an authorised claim for performance in short bursts, around eight per cent more maximal strength and fourteen per cent more reps than training alone, and one to two kilograms of lean mass over a block at pence a day; protein as the gram rather than the brand, with 0.3kg of fat-free mass for the lifter below 1.6g per kilogram and nothing above; and caffeine as a tablet at 3 to 6mg per kilogram for the session, which is the pre-workout's measurable effect without the tub.

Do BCAAs work for bodybuilding?

No, in anyone eating adequate protein: the branched-chain amino acids are three of the nine essential amino acids, and the physiology review that examined the question found they cannot sustain muscle protein synthesis on their own because the other six are needed to build the protein, so that a complete protein at a fraction of the price does what the blend claims and the blend adds nothing to it; they were the fifth era's cleverest error, a part sold as more than the whole, and the lifting trials in people eating enough protein are null.

Is creatine the best bodybuilding supplement?

By the history, yes: it is the only product on the shelf's top ten that the trials made bigger rather than smaller, arriving in the third era with a claim it could not yet support and leaving two decades of trials with an authorised claim, a strength meta-analysis of eight per cent more maximal strength and fourteen per cent more reps than training alone, one to two kilograms of lean mass over a block, and a price that fell to pence as the molecule became a commodity; it is bought as plain monohydrate at 3 to 5g a day, since every branded form that followed costs more for the same molecule and no trial shows it doing more.

Are pre-workouts worth it for bodybuilders?

Their measurable effect is their caffeine, which the fourth era's stimulant blends discovered and the fifth era kept: 150 to 300mg a serving giving the lower perceived exertion and extra reps caffeine gives at 3 to 6mg per kilogram, at ten times the price of a tablet, surrounded by arginine or citrulline for a pump with no mass trial and beta-alanine for a tingle that buffers efforts a set does not last; a bodybuilder who wants the effect buys caffeine as a tablet for the sessions that need it and leaves the era around it on the shelf.

Why do bodybuilding supplements keep changing?

Because each era's product is sold on a mechanism, the trials test the outcome, and the product either earns a claim, which one did, or becomes a footnote and is replaced by the next era's mechanism: liver tablets gave way to free amino acids, which gave way to creatine, then nitric oxide and pre-workouts, then branched-chain amino acids, boosters and fat burners, and now collagen, greens and nootropics; the three that survive, creatine, protein and caffeine, survived as commodities rather than as the brands that sold them, which is why the shelf needs a new era every few years and the honest cupboard does not.

Sources

1. Kreider RB, et al. International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand: safety and efficacy of creatine supplementation in exercise, sport, and medicine. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 2017;14:18. PubMed record
2. Wolfe RR. Branched-chain amino acids and muscle protein synthesis in humans: myth or reality? Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 2017;14:30: branched-chain amino acids alone cannot sustain muscle protein synthesis without the other essential amino acids, so that in people eating adequate protein they add nothing a complete protein does not. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28852372/
3. The 2020 audit of testosterone booster supplements: of fifty top-selling products, under a quarter had any published data showing a testosterone increase for their ingredients, a tenth had data showing a decrease, most had no human data at all, and many exceeded upper intake levels for vitamins and minerals. PubMed record
4. Morton RW, et al. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength. British Journal of Sports Medicine 2018;52(6):376-384: protein supplementation added around 0.3kg of fat-free mass, with the benefit plateauing at total intakes around 1.6g per kilogram a day. PubMed record

Related answers

• What are the top 10 brain supplements in the UK?
• What are the top 10 supplements everyone should take in the UK?
• What are the top 10 supplement brands UK?
• What are the top 10 supplement brands in world in the UK?
• What are the top 3 supplements to take?
• What are the top 5 supplements for men?