What is the best thing to mix with creatine?

The glass test: three things that can happen to creatine in a liquid, which mixers produce which, why grit is not a problem and standing is, and the format that fails the test

What is the best thing to mix with creatine is a question with a long folk history and a short chemistry, and the chemistry is a glass test. Put a teaspoon of creatine monohydrate in a liquid and one of three things happens. It dissolves, which it does fully in a warm liquid and only partly in a cold one, because its solubility rises steeply with temperature. It sits as a suspension, the gritty layer at the bottom of a cold glass that every lifter has swirled, which is undissolved powder and not degraded powder. Or, given time, it degrades, converting slowly to creatinine, the inert breakdown product, a reaction that does not happen to dry powder in any meaningful amount over years but that proceeds in solution, faster as the liquid gets warmer and more acidic. The best thing to mix creatine with is decided by which of those three a person wants, and the answer is that they want the first or the second and not the third, which is a question of time rather than of mixer.

Warm water, or a warm drink, dissolves the daily dose completely and is the cleanest format: a small glass, a stir, no grit, drunk at once. Cold water, juice, squash or a cold shake leaves a suspension, and the gym belief that the grit means the creatine has not been absorbed is wrong; undissolved creatine swallowed is dissolved in the stomach and absorbed as completely as the dissolved kind, so that a cold glass swirled and finished delivers the full dose. The only loss from grit is the grit left in the glass, which is why the glass is swirled and finished rather than sipped and abandoned. Juice adds the acid and the sugar that the folk history has argued about for decades, and the acid matters only over hours, while the sugar is a question the next section answers with a meal. A shake made with milk or a protein powder is as good a mixer as any, dissolves the dose partly, hides the texture completely, and is drunk within the hour, which satisfies the test.

The test is failed by time, not by any mixer. Creatine stirred into a drink and left on a desk for the afternoon, in a bottle in a hot car, or in a pre-made batch in the fridge for the week, degrades a little each day, a few percent in a cold neutral liquid, more in a warm acidic one, and the loss is cumulative. The practical rule is to mix on the day and drink within the hour, which every ordinary mixer allows. The format that fails the test by design is the pre-mixed creatine drink, a liquid product bottled months before sale, in which the degradation has been running since the factory and in which the labelled dose and the delivered dose can differ by a margin the buyer cannot see; the stability studies are the reason powder is the strong format and ready-to-drink creatine is the weak one, and the price difference runs the wrong way. Chewable tablets and capsules pass the test, being dry, at a higher cost per gram and with the capsule count for a 5g dose running to several.

Three fates and a rule about time rather than mixer, and the carbohydrate question, the caffeine entry, the acid myth and the verdict, which is the next section.

The carbohydrate and protein question answered by the meal, the caffeine entry separated by hours, the acidic-drink myth retired, the capsule beside the glass, and the verdict

The folk history's main argument is about sugar, and it has a real study behind it. Early trials found that taking creatine with a large dose of carbohydrate, around 90g of simple sugar, increased the muscle's uptake of creatine compared with creatine alone, through insulin's effect on the transporter, and the finding became the rule that creatine should be mixed with grape juice or dextrose. The later work refined it: a smaller mix of carbohydrate and protein produced a similar increase in uptake, and the reviews concluded that the practical version of the finding is to take the daily dose with a meal, which delivers carbohydrate and protein together and an insulin response without 90g of sugar that a person did not otherwise want. For a lifter, the best thing to mix creatine with is therefore not a liquid at all but a mealtime: stirred into the drink that accompanies breakfast or dinner, or into the protein shake that is itself a protein and carbohydrate mix, and the sugar drink is retired. Once muscle stores are saturated, which takes around twenty-eight daily doses at 3g or a short loading period, the uptake question matters less still, because the daily dose is replacing a small daily loss rather than filling an empty store.

Caffeine enters as the one disputed mixer. Creatine stirred into a coffee is a warm drink that dissolves it well, and the chemistry is fine; the question is the interaction, where one early study found that daily caffeine during loading blunted creatine's effect, later trials did not consistently reproduce it, and the one reliable finding was stomach discomfort when both were taken together in a large dose. The practical reading, covered in full on the page on what not to take with creatine, is to keep them a few hours apart: creatine with a meal, caffeine before the session, which removes the stomach problem and any plausible version of the blunting. A coffee is a good solvent and a poor habit for the creatine dose, and tea stands in for it as a warm mixer without the dose.

The acidic-drink myth deserves retiring in one sentence. Orange juice and other acidic drinks were said to destroy creatine, on the basis of the degradation chemistry, and the chemistry is real but the timescale is hours to days rather than the minutes a glass of juice takes to drink, so that creatine in juice drunk within the hour is delivered intact and only juice left standing all day loses a few percent. The stomach is more acidic than any juice and the creatine survives it, which should settle the matter. The one liquid to avoid is hot: boiling water degrades the powder faster, and a warm drink rather than a scalding one is the cleanest mixer.

The worked example sits beside the glass rather than in it, because it is swallowed as a capsule with the same meal: {FL}, 1500mg magnesium bisglycinate stated as 300mg elemental at 80% NRV, two capsules with the evening meal, authorised for normal muscle function, normal protein synthesis and electrolyte balance, with no interaction with creatine and no mixing question, batch tested for lead, mercury, arsenic and cadmium, UK made, 180 capsules for £19.99 at 22p a day. The full label breakdown is here.

The verdict: the best thing to mix creatine with is whatever will be finished within the hour at a mealtime. Warm water dissolves it fully; cold water, juice or a shake leaves grit that is swallowed and absorbed; a meal supplies the carbohydrate and protein the sugar-drink rule was reaching for; caffeine is kept a few hours away; and nothing is left standing, which is why powder on the day beats any pre-mixed bottle.

What to check on the label

Questions people also ask

Should creatine be mixed with warm or cold water?

Either works for absorption and warm is cleaner: creatine's solubility rises steeply with temperature, so warm water or tea dissolves the daily dose fully with no grit, while cold water leaves an undissolved layer that is still absorbed completely once swallowed, because the stomach dissolves it; the grit is powder that has not dissolved rather than powder that has degraded, so a cold glass swirled and finished delivers the full dose, and the only liquid to avoid is boiling, which speeds degradation.

Does orange juice destroy creatine?

No, on the timescale of drinking it: the degradation of creatine to creatinine is real and runs faster in acidic liquid, but it takes hours to days to lose a few percent, not the minutes a glass of juice takes to finish, and the stomach is more acidic than any juice and the creatine survives it; juice drunk within the hour delivers the dose intact, and only creatine left standing in juice all day or in a pre-mixed bottle for months loses a meaningful fraction.

Should I take creatine with sugar or carbs?

The early trials found that a large sugar dose of around 90g increased the muscle's uptake through insulin, later work found a smaller carbohydrate and protein mix did as well, and the reviews conclude that taking the daily dose with a meal captures most of the effect without sugar a person did not otherwise want; so the best thing to mix creatine with is a mealtime, stirred into the drink with breakfast or dinner or into a protein shake, and once stores are saturated after around twenty-eight daily doses the uptake question matters less still.

Can I mix creatine with my coffee?

Chemically yes, since a warm coffee dissolves it well, but the interaction is the disputed entry in the creatine register: one early study found daily caffeine during loading blunted creatine's effect, later trials did not consistently reproduce it, and the reliable finding was stomach discomfort when both were taken in one large dose; the practical rule is creatine with a meal and caffeine before the session, a few hours apart, so tea stands in as the warm mixer and the coffee keeps its own slot.

Can I pre-mix creatine for the week?

No; dissolved creatine degrades slowly to creatinine, a few percent a day in a cold neutral liquid and more in a warm or acidic one, and the loss is cumulative, so a batch made for the week delivers less each day and a ready-to-drink creatine bottled months before sale delivers an unknown fraction of its label; dry powder is stable for years, so the rule is to mix on the day and drink within the hour, and capsules or chewable tablets pass the same test at a higher cost per gram.

Sources

1. The creatine stability studies: creatine monohydrate is stable as a dry powder for years but degrades slowly to creatinine once dissolved, faster at low pH and higher temperature, with a few percent lost over a day in a cold drink and more in a warm acidic one, so that pre-mixed liquids are the weak format and powder mixed on the day is the strong one. PubMed record
2. The creatine with carbohydrate studies: taking creatine with a large carbohydrate dose increased muscle creatine accumulation in early trials through an insulin-mediated effect, a smaller carbohydrate and protein mix produced a similar effect, and the practical conclusion in the reviews is that taking the daily dose with a meal captures most of the effect without extra sugar. PubMed record
3. The creatine and caffeine interaction question: one early study found that caffeine taken daily alongside creatine loading blunted the performance effect, later work did not consistently reproduce it, some trials found gastrointestinal discomfort when both were taken in a single large dose, and the reviews conclude the interaction is unresolved and small if real. PubMed record
4. Kreider RB, et al. International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand: safety and efficacy of creatine supplementation in exercise, sport, and medicine. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 2017;14:18. PubMed record

Related answers

• What supplements should not be taken with creatine?
• What to take with creatine for best results?
• What is best to combine with creatine?
• What is the best supplement to pair with creatine?
• What is the best supplement to take with creatine for women?
• What is the best supplement to take with creatine for muscle gain?